McCain must lead the charge


Why is John McCain silent on passing a new GI Bill for our 'new greatest generation?"
Tell John McCain to do the right thing and co-sponsor the new GI Bill.

Click to sign the petition>>

McCain must lead the charge

A new GI Bill needs his support, yet the war-hero candidate appears reluctant.

By Wesley K. Clark and Jon Soltz | Los Angeles Times | April 10, 2008

Sen. John McCain served his nation with honor in Vietnam, and he is right to be proud of his service. But by hedging on whether he will support a "GI Bill for the 21st Century," he is casting doubt on his own commitment to the newest generation of American heroes.

The Post-9/11 Veterans Educational Assistance Act, sponsored by Sens. Jim Webb (D-Va.) and Chuck Hagel (R-Neb.), will restore the promise of a cost-free education to those who serve in the military. The original GI Bill transformed American history, providing education for returning soldiers. The GI Bill not only recognized our nation's moral duty for the enormous sacrifices of our World War II veterans, but it helped create America's middle class and spurred decades of economic growth for our country. Economists estimate that the original bill returned anywhere between $5 and $13 for every dollar we spent on it. But the original GI Bill has become woefully outdated, to the point where the average benefit doesn't even cover half the cost of an in-state student's education at a public college.

The Post-9/11 Veterans Act, which has an estimated cost between $2.5 billion and $4 billion, is common-sense legislation. With 51 cosponsors, including nine Republicans, the three other Vietnam War veterans in the Senate and former Secretary of the Navy John Warner, the bill simply updates what the late historian Stephen Ambrose called "the best piece of legislation ever passed by the U.S. Congress." Yet, faced with unprecedented filibusters, it needs 60 cosponsors. As de facto leader of the party, McCain could signal to other Republicans to sign on to the bill and assure passage.

Instead, McCain has said he hasn't had time to read the bill and isn't sure if he could support it. It's hard to believe that neither he nor anyone on his staff has had time to read such an important bill, which has been around since before he started running for president. But, even if true, McCain must do the right thing now, when his leadership is needed.

Our newest veterans are struggling. Jason Bensley, an Iraq war veteran from Southern California, receives $650 a month from the current GI Bill for his education. Bensley, who served in southern Iraq, Mosul and Diyala province, is in debt, trying to pay for college. "I wouldn't have the faintest idea why a member of Congress wouldn't want to support the GI Bill," he says. "Sen. McCain should know how hard it is for veterans to transition back into civilian life."

The White House has voiced concern on the bill, arguing that if returning troops are offered a good education, they will choose college over extending their service. This is as offensive as it is absurd.

First, it is morally reprehensible to fix the system so that civilian life is unappealing to service members, in an attempt to force them to re-up. Education assistance is not a handout, it is a sacred promise that we have made for generations in return for service.

Second, falling military recruitment numbers are just as serious as retention problems. To send the message that this nation will not help you make the most of your life will dissuade a large number of our best and brightest from choosing military service over other career options.

McCain has made it a point to remind audiences that service to one's nation is bigger than one's self. Indeed, there is nothing more noble than risking your life for your country. Every day, Americans are doing just that, as they serve longer and more frequent deployments in Iraq and Afghanistan.

But just because our service members are selfless does not mean they deserve to be left to fend for themselves as they return home and try to make a better life. Indeed, as much as his service to America is responsible for making McCain who he is today, America's service to him played an invaluable role too. McCain should remember that and sign on to the "GI Bill for the 21st Century."

Submitted by Mitch Dworkin on April 10, 2008 - 4:24pm.

I just signed the petition, there are 25,581 signers so far as of the time of this comment!

DonL's picture
Submitted by DonL on April 10, 2008 - 4:30pm.

but support it, he must.

Senator McCain, it is time for you to do the right thing.

Donald C. Lindsay


jordans11's picture
Submitted by jordans11 on April 10, 2008 - 9:21pm.

If this bill doesn't pass soon.

"People who founded this country...had strong beliefs, but they believed in reason, and dialogue, and civil discourse. We can't lose that in this country. We've got to get it back." - Wes Clark


early-bird's picture
Submitted by early-bird on April 10, 2008 - 9:46pm.

but the GOP are entirely obstructionist: it will take a 60 Senate seats Dem majority ( there are 35 senate seats up for re-election in November ) to pass this bill;

 

 

 

http://www.cs.princeton.edu/~chazelle/pubs/algorithm.html By virtually any measure the United States is the least progressive nation in the developed world.


Stan4Clark's picture
Submitted by Stan4Clark on April 10, 2008 - 11:21pm.

With nine Republicans as co-sponsors, they only need one or two more to get over 60.

Stan Davis
Lakewood, CO
Wes Clark -- Make America All It Can Be!


early-bird's picture
Submitted by early-bird on April 10, 2008 - 11:28pm.

http://www.cs.princeton.edu/~chazelle/pubs/algorithm.html By virtually any measure the United States is the least progressive nation in the developed world.


kaflinn's picture
Submitted by kaflinn on April 11, 2008 - 12:10am.

friends and family, who have been very supportive of McCain. So far, most are both surprised and disappointed to find he isn't backing this. Hopefully, that'll get them to sign the petition too.

"Our public servants work for us - we don't work for them. We have an obligation, as citizens of this country, to always remember that - and to never let them forget it." - DeadMessengers


Nick Kelly's picture
Submitted by Nick Kelly on April 11, 2008 - 3:23pm.

I sent this message to those who I figure to be supporting McCain this morning:

Subject: GI Bill

Dear family and friends,

Please help to get John McCain to lead this effort:

http://securingamerica.com/ccn/node/15179

Nick Kelly

After lunch, I checked my email and already had two positive responses (both from Vets who often disagree with me on politics):

1.

I signed the petition and forwarded it...

2.

Yeah,

I'll support you on this one. I haven't read all of the details of the
program yet (i.e. costs), but I am sure that the amount needs to be
increased, and it does get paid back in spades once these former service
members graduate and start paying more in taxes. GEN Clark neglected to add
that many of these soldiers who go to college on the GI Bill return to the
service as commissioned officers.

General Clark is doing the right thing on this, and every sensible Veteran will realize that. I sincerely hope that Senator McCain comes aboard.

It would be nice to celebrate a bi-partisan victory for our bravest and best.

Nick Kelly

Wes Clark could still secure America as a national security candidate.


kaflinn's picture
Submitted by kaflinn on April 15, 2008 - 12:00am.

eom

"Our public servants work for us - we don't work for them. We have an obligation, as citizens of this country, to always remember that - and to never let them forget it." - DeadMessengers


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.