Howard Kurtz & panel on Hillary's complaints about sexist treatment by the press


Hello Everyone:

Here is the CNN Reliable Sources transcript from Sunday, May 25 where Howard Kurtz opened this program with credible documentation about the media belittling Hillary, Hillary's sexist treatment by the press, and his excellent panel discussion about all of this with Carol Costello, who reports for "THE SITUATION ROOM" on CNN, radio talk show host Blanquita Cullum, and Marie Cocco, syndicated columnist for "The Washington Post Writers Group:"

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0805/25/rs.01.html

CNN RELIABLE SOURCES

Hillary Clinton Complains About Media's Treatment of Women; Interview With Laura Dern

Aired May 25, 2008 - 10:00 ET

HOWARD KURTZ, HOST (voice over): The media and misogyny. Hillary Clinton complains about sexist treatment by the press, and plenty of women seem to agree...

KURTZ: As Hillary Clinton edged another step closer to losing the Democratic nomination this week, the media began to focus on the women out there who are angry. They are angry at seeming to lose the chance to see one of their own in the Oval Office. They are angry at a campaign that has sometimes seemed to focus on Hillary's clothing, cleavage and cackle. And they are angry at the media for belittling their champion.

You can see that in an online video put together by a feminist group and aired on ABC News.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

JACK CAFFERTY, CNN ANCHOR: She morphed into a scolding mother talking down to a child.

NEIL CAVUTO, FOX NEWS: Men won't vote for Hillary Clinton because she reminds them of their nagging wives.

UNIDENTIFIED MALE: And when Hillary Clinton speaks, men hear, "Take out the garbage."

CHRIS MATTHEWS, MSNBC NEWS: They said you're a guy going door to door trying to sell something. And she said, you'll have to wait for my husband to get home.

MIKE BARNICLE, MSNBC CONTRIBUTOR: When she reacts the way she reacts to Obama, with just the look, the look toward him, looking like everyone's first wife standing outside of probate court...

(END VIDEO CLIP)

KURTZ: Hillary herself used her strongest language to date in an interview with The Washington Post's Lois Romano.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

SEN. HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON (D-NY), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: It's been deeply offensive to millions of women. The manifestation of some of the sexism that has gone on in this campaign is somehow more respectable, or at least more accepted. And I think there should be equal rejection of the sexism and the racism when and if it ever raises its ugly head. But it does seem as though the press, at least, is not as bothered by the incredible vitriol that has been engendered by the comments and the actions of people who are nothing by misogynists.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

KURTZ: Joining us now to talk about this, in Baltimore, Carol Costello, who reports for "THE SITUATION ROOM" on CNN. And here in Washington, radio talk show host Blanquita Cullum. And Marie Cocco, syndicated columnist for "The Washington Post Writers Group."

Marie Cocco, what are some of the swipes and slams against Hillary that have bothered you most in the coverage of this campaign? Have we enabled this? Have we allowed this?

MARIE COCCO, SYNDICATED COLUMNIST, "THE WASHINGTON POST WRITERS GROUP": Sure. You know, sometimes you put on cable television and you feel like you're in the middle of a locker room.

One of the most memorable lines was last fall, actually, when Tucker Carlson, on MSNBC, was calling Senator Clinton scary and said, you know, "Every time she comes on TV, I instinctively cross my legs." Chris Matthews has said that the male politicians, prominent male politicians, governors, senators who were endorsing Senator Clinton last fall were "castrados in the eunuch chorus."

KURTZ: All right.

Blanquita Cullum, when Hillary Clinton complains about sexism and misogyny in the media, doesn't being a woman, as a candidate, also help her?

BLANQUITA CULLUM, RADIO TALK SHOW HOST: Not really. I've got to say that it hurts her, because the rules are different.

The rules are a lot harder for her, and people -- I think there's almost more sexism than there is racism in this country. And frankly, as you know, she's not been my candidate, but I have to say that I have to really admire her ability to continue almost like a battering ram against her own party that has been the worst in trying to take her down and make her quit.

And a lot of people are watching that and they're saying -- you know, they're secretly behind the scenes saying, you go for it, because you have a right as a candidate to run. And it's not your sex.

KURTZ: You just touched on something that I want to toss to Carol Costello. And that is, do commentators say things about a female candidate, and do journalists quote people as saying things that you could never get away with if somebody were belittling a black candidate?

CAROL COSTELLO, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Oh, I think that's absolutely true. I think it's OK to say sexist remarks about women in this country. And the best example of that is, remember when that woman stood up at a John McCain campaign rally and she saw that a camera was rolling, she was very well dressed, and she came out and said, "How can we beat the bitch?"

Everybody covered it from John McCain's perspective and how he responded to this woman, but nobody really covered it from this woman's perspective. I mean, what exactly made it OK for her to stand up in front of a rolling camera at a public event and call another woman this name?

CULLUM: And Carol, to that point, you have a situation where people belittled Bill Clinton for telling people, back off on my wife, but no one has said anything to Barack Obama, who made the same statement about his wife...

KURTZ: We'll get to that.

CUMMINGS: ... and told them to back off.

COSTELLO: That's chivalrous. I mean, a man can say that about his wife and that's fine, but Bill Clinton saying that about Hillary is like they want a co-presidency. It's never taken in the same context as what a man would say about his spouse.

KURTZ: But Marie Cocco, are the media being tarred with a pretty broad brush here because of the out-of-bounds comments of a certain number of loudmouths?

COCCO: Well, this is amplified on the Internet, which, you know, may not be the broadcast media, but it is part of the media of this campaign. And if you went to the Internet -- you know, we all know about the false Muslim e-mails that go around about Barack Obama. But if you ever saw the language, the vulgarity, the vitriol that is hauled at Hillary Clinton by liberal Democrats, by the liberal blogs, largely by, frankly, Obama supporters, you'd be appalled. I mean, you'd punish your children for this.

And what I keep coming back to -- and I'm really glad the event with Senator McCain was mentioned, because Senator McCain could have said at that moment, I will accept the premise of your question, which is how am I, the Republican...

KURTZ: But I don't want to talk about Senator McCain. I want to talk about the media. The media played that clip over and over and over again. And yes, it was all couched in terms of the political calculations of John McCain.

COCCO: Right.

KURTZ: Why is it -- is it just that we reflect the culture, that there is a media culture that says it's OK to throw these terms around...

COCCO: Well, you know what, Howard?

KURTZ: ... and talk about the first wives and all of that -- yes.

COCCO: Don Imus was the media culture too. And what happened to Don Imus when he made a sexist and racist comment about the Rutgers women's basketball team? The media pounced on him, the mainstream media pounced on him. The political class pounced on him.

I cannot count the number of politicians who went on television who went on television to denounce Don Imus. And he was basically driven out of his job.

KURTZ: OK.

COSTELLO: Yes, yes, but on the...

KURTZ: Go ahead, Carol.

COSTELLO: But Don Imus, I think it's because the women he maligned were African-American. If they weren't and they were white women, I really believe that nothing would have been said.

CULLUM: And the other part of this is, it's a very fine line, OK? First of all, when you're running for any high office, and especially as it becomes more apparent in a race for the presidency, you know right out front, right out front you've got to be ready for the maligns and the slurs. And as you're right, Maria, when it comes to the Internet, where it's absolutely bigoted, racist, horrible.

Now, I will tell you, I would rather see someone of a strength of character go out there and run and not limit the free speech, because at least you know where people lie and their biases.

KURTZ: All right.

Now Carol, is this -- let me ask you a two-part question. One is, is this allowed, does this flourish because we have a male- dominated media culture in which mostly male executives make these decisions about the tone of what's acceptable? And also, as a woman -- and you're a journalist, you don't take sides -- but when you see a candidate who happens to be a woman like Hillary Clinton getting slapped around like this, does it bother you personally?

COSTELLO: It does bother me personally. I mean, it deeply bothers me. And you know, I've done many stories on "THE SITUATION ROOM" on this.

Something I would like to say, you know, we sit around and we blame males for sexist comments, but women are guilty as well. I remember Jane Fonda came out and called Hillary Clinton, what, a "patriarch with a vagina"?

Laura Ingraham, the conservative radio talk show host, played the Wicked Witch of the West music every time she talked about Hillary Clinton. Randi Rhodes, a liberal woman talker, she called Hillary Clinton a term I cannot say on television, but at least she was fired about it.

But women play into this sexist culture as well because -- you know, explain to me, ladies, why women do this when they have been in the same place as Hillary Clinton, fighting to get to the top. They know what it's like and yet they play into this.

KURTZ: Right.

COSTELLO: And they get away with it because the media doesn't cover that part. It's OK if a woman says it about another woman.

KURTZ: That's an excellent point. And we shouldn't hang it all on men because you gave all the examples.

I need to move on now..."

I wish that CNN made a video of this dialogue because it was excellent in my opinion.

Howard Kurtz and his show CNN Reliable Sources in my opinion are like the Eliot Ness of the media. Kurtz is one good media cop who cannot be bought off and he will expose media corruption as he honestly sees it!

Please forward this important information on so that people know the truth about the hit job that the media is doing on Hillary right now which in my opinion is a huge reason why Obama is in the position that he is in right now!

Mitch Dworkin

http://www.securingamerica.com/

http://securingamerica.com/ccn/node/10756
StopIranWar.com: "War is not the answer"
Submitted by Wes Clark on February 21, 2007 - 11:40am.

http://www.securingamerica.com/ccn/node/7191
Listen to Gen. Wes Clark fight for Dems on Sean Hannity's radio program: An excellent example for all of us to follow and what we all need to be doing to help fight back against extreme right wing Neocon smear propaganda!

Submitted by Mitch Dworkin on May 27, 2008 - 9:34am.

http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2008/05/25/columnist-sexism-campaign-liberal-blogs-obama-supporters

Columnist: Sexism in Campaign from Liberal Blogs and Obama Supporters


By Noel Sheppard | May 25, 2008 - 11:10 ET

Here's something you don't see every day: a female member of the media blaming the sexism and misogyny in the presidential campaign on liberal Democrats, liberal bloggers, and Barack Obama supporters.

Yet, that's what occurred Sunday morning when syndicated columnist Marie Cocco was invited on CNN's "Reliable Sources" to discuss the role sexism and misogyny have played in this election cycle.

Fasten those seatbelts tightly, for you're about to enter an alternate reality (picture courtesy Washington Post Writers Group):

Well, this is amplified on the Internet, which may not be the broadcast media, but, but it is part of the media of this campaign. And if you went to the Internet, you know we all know about the false Muslim e-mails that go around about Barack Obama. But if you ever saw the language, the vulgarity, the vitriol that is hurled at Hillary Clinton by liberal Democrats, by the liberal blogs, largely by, frankly, Obama supporters, you'd be appalled. I mean, you'd punish your children for this.

As it appears that sexism and misogyny are now going to be blamed for Hillary's failure, will media be as honest about the causes and the sources as Cocco?
Stay tuned.         

Noel Sheppard's blog
Login or register to post comments
Printer friendly version
Topics:
2008 Presidential
Campaigns & Elections
Culture/Society
Feminism
Barack Obama
Hillary Clinton
Marie Cocco
Online Media
Blogs
CNN
Daily Kos
Huffington Post
Reliable Sources

AnitaInTX's picture
Submitted by AnitaInTX on May 27, 2008 - 10:52am.

I wish I had seen this program and I'm glad to hear that it *does* bother women newscasters. But we hear little of this...


Submitted by briarhopper on May 27, 2008 - 1:24pm.

to pieces because they're doing it to advance a minority candidate. And, of course, she's just the worthless wife of hillbilly Bill, so whatever it takes is okey-dokey!
I'd like for the media to also investigate how many men are turned off by this misogyny. Most of the men I encounter still open the door for me and address me as "ma'am" if they don't know me. I've personally had men tell me they're distressed (and probably embarrassed) by such vicious treatment of a woman.
Barack Obama should not have sat on the sidelines and let minions do this hatchet-job for him. You'd never know, from listening to the MSM, how much of a negative effect this must be having on him. When WV and KY gave him the cold shoulder, the pundits pretty much sat mute or blew it off as "regional". They have no idea what everyday, working people think about it.

Submitted by Mitch Dworkin on May 27, 2008 - 11:16pm.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0805/26/sitroom.03.html

THE SITUATION ROOM

Memorial Day Politics; Interview With Former U.S. Senator Bob Graham

Aired May 26, 2008 - 18:00 ET

WOLF BLITZER, CNN ANCHOR: Happening now, Bill Clinton says he's never seen a candidate treated as disrespectfully as he claims his wife is being treated right now. We will go inside his allegation that people are trying to force Hillary Clinton out of the race...

I'm Wolf Blitzer. You're in THE SITUATION ROOM.

In the race for the White House, Bill Clinton is making news once again out on the campaign trail, asking voters and delegates not to write off his wife.

Let's go back to CNN's Brian Todd. He's watching this story for us.

Brian, what's going on?

BRIAN TODD, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Wolf, the former president says his wife's campaign is not always getting a fair shot, and, this time, it's not a vast right-wing conspiracy that's to blame. Mr. Clinton says, every time you turn on the TV, someone is trying to end this race.

(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE) TODD (voice-over): The former president tells voters to ignore calls by -- quote -- "people on television" for Hillary Clinton to drop out and says she's been getting a raw deal throughout the campaign.

W. CLINTON: And I have never seen anything like it. I have never seen a candidate treated so disrespectfully just for running.

TODD: Pleading for time, he tells an audience in South Dakota his wife still has a chance.

W. CLINTON: Why have all these people tried to run her out of this race? They're trying to get her to cry uncle before the Democratic Party has to decide what to do in Florida and Michigan.

TODD: The former president says he also sees an effort afoot to strong-arm undecided superdelegates to make their choice fast.

W. CLINTON: I can't believe it. It's just frantic, the way they're trying to push and pressure and bully all these superdelegates to come out.

TODD: But her rival, Senator Barack Obama, is taking the high road, praising her at every opportunity.

OBAMA: She has set the standard. She has broken through barriers, and will open up opportunity for a lot of people, including my two young daughters.

SUSAN PAGE, WASHINGTON BUREAU CHIEF, "USA TODAY": Well, he doesn't want her to feel disrespected and her followers to feel that she's been disrespected.

TODD: Will that be enough for Obama to win over her voters if he becomes the Democratic nominee?

ROGER SIMON, CHIEF POLITICAL COLUMNIST, THEPOLITICO.COM: A lot of her supporters, women supporters, feel that she definitely has not been treated respectfully, and they believe that the best sign of respect that Barack Obama could deliver is to pick her as his vice president.

(END VIDEOTAPE)

TODD: Even Bill Clinton himself reportedly believes that, if she does not win the nomination, that she has still earned a shot at the number-two slot. But, for now, Hillary and Bill Clinton are still focused on the top job, campaigning together today in Puerto Rico -- Wolf.

BLITZER: Brian, thanks very much -- Brian Todd reporting...

Submitted by Mitch Dworkin on May 28, 2008 - 12:02am.

http://newsbusters.org/blogs/mark-finkelstein/2008/05/27/hardballs-haggard-hillary-promo-pic

Hardball's Haggard Hillary Promo Pic


By Mark Finkelstein | May 27, 2008 - 06:56 ET

If NewsBusters were ever to use in its promotional material a photo this unflattering of Hillary Clinton, we'd be accused of the worst kind of sexism, of unfairly attacking a candidate based on her looks rather than her views. Check out the image of Hillary that MSNBC used in its promo of tonight's Hardball with Chris Matthews that aired at 5:59 AM EDT today just before Morning Joe came on the air.

Hillary, shot from below to highlight her wattles, lit like something in a horror flick about to emerge from a closet wielding an ax. If there's a less-becoming snap of Hillary in MSM circulation, I haven't seen it.

View video of promo, and Carlson's comments, here.

Can you blame ardent Clinton camper Lanny Davis for accusing MSNBC, and Matthews in particular, of being "shamelessly biased" against Clinton? Ironically, during Morning Joe's first segment, panelist Tucker Carlson discussed the same phenomenon, describing "the overwhelming press bias in favor of Barack Obama."

Davis says that a member of MSNBC senior management “told me personally that they were aware that they needed to do something to bring credibility back to MSNBC in terms of balance,” and that Matthews himself told Lanny “I’m going to be better.”

Looks like MSNBC needs to go back to the fair-and-balanced drawing board.

Should you wish to inspect the evidence more carefully, click here for a larger version of the Hillary pic. Warning: not suitable for children under 11.

http://newsbusters.org/static/2008/05/2008-05-27MSNBCHBpromoHillary2.jpg        

Mark Finkelstein's blog
Login or register to post comments
Printer friendly version
Topics:
2008 Presidential
Campaigns & Elections
Culture/Society
Feminism
Chris Matthews
Hillary Clinton
Lanny Davis
Tucker Carlson
Hardball
Morning Joe
MSNBC

Submitted by briarhopper on May 28, 2008 - 9:10am.

And Tweety and his slimey ilk are going to "do better"? It's way, way too late.
All these promises, including that of putting her on the ticket, sound like the saccharine persuasions of a man who just beat the heck out of his wife and now wants some lovin'!
In the first place, it's incredible that Bill Clinton is flitting around, begging for a veep slot. And why would Hillary want to hitch herself to a sure loser? And, let's face it, that's exactly what BO would be, and no credible person can deny it! Her being on the ticket is not going to do it for voters who fear BO or for women who've been sickened and outraged by the misogyny that he has either contributed to or tacitly sanctioned! An Obama ticket will be poison, and any pol that gets on it will be permanently tainted.

Submitted by Mitch Dworkin on May 28, 2008 - 9:59am.

NewsBusters is a GOP activist media watchdog website!

How can we fight against them in the general election IF Obama is the nominee when I think that they are right about a lot of the things they are saying regarding Obama and MSNBC?

I will definitely not put my credibility on the line to try and defend what cannot be reasonably defended IF Obama is the nominee. I hope that Democratic Party leaders and superdelegates will keep this in mind when they are making key decisions so that they do not wonder why so many Hillary supporters won't support Obama in the general election IF they decide to give him the nomination!

Submitted by CentralMass on May 29, 2008 - 7:33am.

Still, it can't be easy for Obama. Carrying the burdon of Chris Mattews humping his leg and Keith Olbermann with a permanent lip-lock on his backside.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.